Post by eurofed on Dec 8, 2016 7:49:51 GMT
I have already posted elsewhere a variant of this strategic scenario, which developed it with a PoD occurring during WWII, and made its version of the Cold War unfold in similar circumstances as the ones we are familiar with. In this version, similar ATL Cold War conditions get established during the interwar period in Europe and Asia as a result of a divergence occurring in the immediate aftermath WWI and the Russian Revolution. Because of the different origin, certain features get to be substantially different from OTL or the post-WWII ATL versions (isolationist America, not so weakened British Empire, intact and sane Germany and Japan, fascism is essentially prevented, slower decolonization, etc.).
Things more or less began to diverge when the Reds reaped more military success than OTL in the Finnish and Russian civil wars. This allowed the Communists to overrun Finland and the Baltic states, and to crush the Russian Whites quicker and easier than OTL. It also put the Soviets in a position to provide timely support to the Hungarian Soviet Republic which allowed it to win the upper hand in its conflicts with its neighbors. These successes emboldened the victorious Soviet leaders to double down and try their hand at exporting the Revolution across Europe by force. They were vaguely aware of the serious logistic and exhaustion problems a Soviet invasion of Europe immediately after WWI and the RCW would face, but they were confident revolutionary fervor and Communist insurrectionary activism across the continent would make up for the difference.
For a while it seemed like their bold assumptions were right since the Red Army crushed the Poles and cooperated with the HSR to defeat the Czechoslovaks and the Romanians in a two-front war. In relatively quick order, Poland, Slovakia, and Romania were overrun. These successes enabled the Soviets to pull the Bulgarians to their side and stage a Communist takeover in Bulgaria. They made use of the traditional good feelings between the Russians and the Bulgarians and promises of a reversal of Bulgaria’s humiliation in WWI.
Despite the traditional and recent enmity between the Russians and the Ottomans, the threatened dismemberment of the Turkey by Greece and the Entente powers drove the Turk nationalists in an alliance of convenience with the Soviets. Unlike Hungary and Bulgaria, however, the Turk nationalists mostly stayed in control and were able to prevent a Communist takeover of their land.
The Soviet-Hungarian-Bulgarian-Turk alliance defeated the Serbs, pushed back the Greeks, and overrun vast tracts of the Balkans. By then the Red Army was facing serious logistic and overextension problems at the frontline, and was largely running on fumes. However their successes made the Soviet leaders confident world revolution was at hand, so they ordered the Red Army to invade Germany and instructed Communist parties to stage uprisings across Europe.
A wave of strikes, riots, and civil disorders occurred in several capitalist countries, most seriously in Germany, France, Italy, Belgium, and Austria, where it took the form of armed uprisings. To a less severe degree, disorders also occurred in Britain, the Dominions, the USA, and Japan. Comintern-backed agitation and rebellion arose in India, China, and the Arab lands.
Ultimately, however, the Western governments and regular armies, variously supported by right-wing militias and foreign allies, were able to put down the Communist rebellions. The Germans quickly rearmed and reorganized their army to fight back the Soviet invasion. They got the support of the British, Americans, and Italians that switched to regard the Reds a worse danger than a resurgent Germany. The French initially stood in opposition and even attempted to check the German comeback with an abortive invasion of the Rhineland. The potentially disastrous French drive soon collapsed because of German resistance, unrest at home, the opposition and sabotage of the other Entente powers, and the threatened mutiny of the French soldiers that had lost their appetite for aggressive wars of revenge.
As a rule, the German troops fought with considerably more determination since they were defending their homeland from invasion. So they were able to push back the overextended Soviet invasion; the Germans made an alliance with the Czechs and the Poles, and their counteroffensive swept Bohemia-Moravia and western Poland. In a similar way, the Greeks painfully fought back the Soviets and their allies from their territory with the help of an Entente expeditionary corps. However they were forced to withdraw from western Anatolia. The Italians intervened in the Western Balkans after forming their own alliance with the Albanians, Slovenes, and Croats. The Italian soldiers got persuaded to fight competently by the perceived necessity of forestalling an invasion of Italy and protecting the irredentist claims in the region.
Various interventions by the French, Dutch, British, Germans, and Italians helped put down the unrest in minor nations and the colonies. Acting in concert, the Germans and the Italians conquered western Hungary. The European counteroffensive, the failure of Communist revolution in Western Europe, and the threatened rise of anti-Bolshevik resistance in Russia and conquered Eastern Europe persuaded the Soviet leaders of the necessity of a compromise peace. More or less the same way, creeping war exhaustion, Franco-German antagonism and mutual distrust, and the looming threat of revolutionary collapse drove the necessity of a compromise peace in the minds of the Western leaders.
So WWI and the Russian Revolutionary Wars at last came to an end. A compromise peace was agreed upon between Germany, the Entente powers, the Soviets, and Turkey. The leaders of the capitalist powers got persuaded that a Communist takeover of Europe had been barely avoided, and to contain a resurgence of the same threat a reasonable compromise deal to restore goodwill between former enemies was imperative.
By the terms of the peace agreement, the Communists remained in control of the lands of the former Russian Empire, including Finland, the Baltic states, and eastern Poland (up to the Narew-Vistula line). They also got Slovakia, eastern Hungary (up to the Danube), Romania, Bulgaria, Serbia, Montenegro, Macedonia, and Bosnia. Within the Soviet leadership, a clash occurred between Lenin’s unitary view and Stalin’s autonomist argument about the proper disposition of the conquered nations of Eastern Europe. As a compromise Finland, the Baltic states, eastern Poland, Slovakia, eastern Hungary and Romania were incorporated as various SSRs into the newly-established USSR. Bulgaria, Serbia, Montenegro, Macedonia, and Bosnia instead formed a Communist Balkan Federation.
The Communist army and secret police brutally crushed any resistance to Soviet rule in the conquered lands. A wave of Russian and Eastern European refugees fled the Red Terror into the Western nations. As a rule, however, the nationalities that had showed greater cooperation with the Soviets during the war got a more lenient treatment and a preferential deal as it concerned territorial settlements. The peoples that had resisted conquest to the bitter end got the opposite. Nationalist Turkey kept Anatolia, eastern Thrace, and the Turkish Straits. The Turk leaders stayed friendly to the USSR, although they refused to join the Balkan Federation. They were wary of excessive Soviet influence in their country and wished to avoid another general war with the European powers.
France annexed Alsace-Lorraine, Wallonia, and Luxemburg. It was going to receive a fair amount of reparations from Germany to account for the damage the war had wrought on its northern and eastern regions. However the terms the powers agreed upon ensured the reparations would be sustainable for German economy. The Netherlands annexed the Flanders. France and Germany agreed to keep military parity of their land forces (subject to revision in case of Soviet threat) and establish a strip of demilitarized territory on both sides of their border. The powers agreed to cast all the blame for the war on the defunct regimes of Russia, Austria-Hungary, and Serbia.
Germany ceded Alsace-Lorraine to France and Posen to Poland. It annexed Austria and the Sudetenland. Plebiscites confirmed its ownership of West Prussia and Upper Silesia with large majorities. After the Soviet invasion, many Pole inhabitants of these areas came to regard Germany as a better option than the fragile western Polish state. Germany guaranteed the Poles and the Czechs free use of several German ports. It was returned Cameroon and awarded Belgian Congo as compensation for the loss of its other colonies. However the French and the Germans eventually agreed to swap Cameroon for Middle Congo and Gabon.
Italy annexed South Tyrol, the Kustenland, central Dalmatia, and many Adriatic islands. It got a protectorate over Carniola and Albania. A strip of demilitarized territory was established on both sides of the German-Italian border, with similar terms as the Franco-German deal. Britain and Italy agreed to cede Cyprus and the Dodecanese to Greece to reinforce it against the USSR and Turkey, in exchange for basing rights in various Greek ports. Poland (up to the Narew-Vistula line), Czechia, Hungary (up to the Danube), and Croatia got independence, and found themselves in the uneasy role of Europe’s frontline against the Soviet colossus. The other great powers agreed to recognize Ethiopia in the Italian sphere of influence, and soon afterwards the Italians conquered and annexed it.
Things more or less began to diverge when the Reds reaped more military success than OTL in the Finnish and Russian civil wars. This allowed the Communists to overrun Finland and the Baltic states, and to crush the Russian Whites quicker and easier than OTL. It also put the Soviets in a position to provide timely support to the Hungarian Soviet Republic which allowed it to win the upper hand in its conflicts with its neighbors. These successes emboldened the victorious Soviet leaders to double down and try their hand at exporting the Revolution across Europe by force. They were vaguely aware of the serious logistic and exhaustion problems a Soviet invasion of Europe immediately after WWI and the RCW would face, but they were confident revolutionary fervor and Communist insurrectionary activism across the continent would make up for the difference.
For a while it seemed like their bold assumptions were right since the Red Army crushed the Poles and cooperated with the HSR to defeat the Czechoslovaks and the Romanians in a two-front war. In relatively quick order, Poland, Slovakia, and Romania were overrun. These successes enabled the Soviets to pull the Bulgarians to their side and stage a Communist takeover in Bulgaria. They made use of the traditional good feelings between the Russians and the Bulgarians and promises of a reversal of Bulgaria’s humiliation in WWI.
Despite the traditional and recent enmity between the Russians and the Ottomans, the threatened dismemberment of the Turkey by Greece and the Entente powers drove the Turk nationalists in an alliance of convenience with the Soviets. Unlike Hungary and Bulgaria, however, the Turk nationalists mostly stayed in control and were able to prevent a Communist takeover of their land.
The Soviet-Hungarian-Bulgarian-Turk alliance defeated the Serbs, pushed back the Greeks, and overrun vast tracts of the Balkans. By then the Red Army was facing serious logistic and overextension problems at the frontline, and was largely running on fumes. However their successes made the Soviet leaders confident world revolution was at hand, so they ordered the Red Army to invade Germany and instructed Communist parties to stage uprisings across Europe.
A wave of strikes, riots, and civil disorders occurred in several capitalist countries, most seriously in Germany, France, Italy, Belgium, and Austria, where it took the form of armed uprisings. To a less severe degree, disorders also occurred in Britain, the Dominions, the USA, and Japan. Comintern-backed agitation and rebellion arose in India, China, and the Arab lands.
Ultimately, however, the Western governments and regular armies, variously supported by right-wing militias and foreign allies, were able to put down the Communist rebellions. The Germans quickly rearmed and reorganized their army to fight back the Soviet invasion. They got the support of the British, Americans, and Italians that switched to regard the Reds a worse danger than a resurgent Germany. The French initially stood in opposition and even attempted to check the German comeback with an abortive invasion of the Rhineland. The potentially disastrous French drive soon collapsed because of German resistance, unrest at home, the opposition and sabotage of the other Entente powers, and the threatened mutiny of the French soldiers that had lost their appetite for aggressive wars of revenge.
As a rule, the German troops fought with considerably more determination since they were defending their homeland from invasion. So they were able to push back the overextended Soviet invasion; the Germans made an alliance with the Czechs and the Poles, and their counteroffensive swept Bohemia-Moravia and western Poland. In a similar way, the Greeks painfully fought back the Soviets and their allies from their territory with the help of an Entente expeditionary corps. However they were forced to withdraw from western Anatolia. The Italians intervened in the Western Balkans after forming their own alliance with the Albanians, Slovenes, and Croats. The Italian soldiers got persuaded to fight competently by the perceived necessity of forestalling an invasion of Italy and protecting the irredentist claims in the region.
Various interventions by the French, Dutch, British, Germans, and Italians helped put down the unrest in minor nations and the colonies. Acting in concert, the Germans and the Italians conquered western Hungary. The European counteroffensive, the failure of Communist revolution in Western Europe, and the threatened rise of anti-Bolshevik resistance in Russia and conquered Eastern Europe persuaded the Soviet leaders of the necessity of a compromise peace. More or less the same way, creeping war exhaustion, Franco-German antagonism and mutual distrust, and the looming threat of revolutionary collapse drove the necessity of a compromise peace in the minds of the Western leaders.
So WWI and the Russian Revolutionary Wars at last came to an end. A compromise peace was agreed upon between Germany, the Entente powers, the Soviets, and Turkey. The leaders of the capitalist powers got persuaded that a Communist takeover of Europe had been barely avoided, and to contain a resurgence of the same threat a reasonable compromise deal to restore goodwill between former enemies was imperative.
By the terms of the peace agreement, the Communists remained in control of the lands of the former Russian Empire, including Finland, the Baltic states, and eastern Poland (up to the Narew-Vistula line). They also got Slovakia, eastern Hungary (up to the Danube), Romania, Bulgaria, Serbia, Montenegro, Macedonia, and Bosnia. Within the Soviet leadership, a clash occurred between Lenin’s unitary view and Stalin’s autonomist argument about the proper disposition of the conquered nations of Eastern Europe. As a compromise Finland, the Baltic states, eastern Poland, Slovakia, eastern Hungary and Romania were incorporated as various SSRs into the newly-established USSR. Bulgaria, Serbia, Montenegro, Macedonia, and Bosnia instead formed a Communist Balkan Federation.
The Communist army and secret police brutally crushed any resistance to Soviet rule in the conquered lands. A wave of Russian and Eastern European refugees fled the Red Terror into the Western nations. As a rule, however, the nationalities that had showed greater cooperation with the Soviets during the war got a more lenient treatment and a preferential deal as it concerned territorial settlements. The peoples that had resisted conquest to the bitter end got the opposite. Nationalist Turkey kept Anatolia, eastern Thrace, and the Turkish Straits. The Turk leaders stayed friendly to the USSR, although they refused to join the Balkan Federation. They were wary of excessive Soviet influence in their country and wished to avoid another general war with the European powers.
France annexed Alsace-Lorraine, Wallonia, and Luxemburg. It was going to receive a fair amount of reparations from Germany to account for the damage the war had wrought on its northern and eastern regions. However the terms the powers agreed upon ensured the reparations would be sustainable for German economy. The Netherlands annexed the Flanders. France and Germany agreed to keep military parity of their land forces (subject to revision in case of Soviet threat) and establish a strip of demilitarized territory on both sides of their border. The powers agreed to cast all the blame for the war on the defunct regimes of Russia, Austria-Hungary, and Serbia.
Germany ceded Alsace-Lorraine to France and Posen to Poland. It annexed Austria and the Sudetenland. Plebiscites confirmed its ownership of West Prussia and Upper Silesia with large majorities. After the Soviet invasion, many Pole inhabitants of these areas came to regard Germany as a better option than the fragile western Polish state. Germany guaranteed the Poles and the Czechs free use of several German ports. It was returned Cameroon and awarded Belgian Congo as compensation for the loss of its other colonies. However the French and the Germans eventually agreed to swap Cameroon for Middle Congo and Gabon.
Italy annexed South Tyrol, the Kustenland, central Dalmatia, and many Adriatic islands. It got a protectorate over Carniola and Albania. A strip of demilitarized territory was established on both sides of the German-Italian border, with similar terms as the Franco-German deal. Britain and Italy agreed to cede Cyprus and the Dodecanese to Greece to reinforce it against the USSR and Turkey, in exchange for basing rights in various Greek ports. Poland (up to the Narew-Vistula line), Czechia, Hungary (up to the Danube), and Croatia got independence, and found themselves in the uneasy role of Europe’s frontline against the Soviet colossus. The other great powers agreed to recognize Ethiopia in the Italian sphere of influence, and soon afterwards the Italians conquered and annexed it.