Post by eurofed on Jun 11, 2017 20:45:28 GMT
The main idea of this scenario is WWI and the subsequent revolutionary wave unfold in such a way as to become even greater a transformative event than OTL. Notable consequences of this include: the USSR takes over Eastern Europe and the Near East; Western Europe (Germany, France, Italy, and Spain) stabilizes under a social-democratic regime, repudiates nationalism and extremism, and bonds in a fully-realized, federal EU; the British Empire half goes Nazi-fascist and swallows the European colonial empires, half merges with the USA; European far-right immigrants turn North Africa into a giant, Nazi-fascist analogue of Israel; the USA turns more progressive than OTL (the Progressive Era and the New Deal effectively fuse into one) and absorbs the rest of North America and Oceania; Japan becomes liberal and builds an empire across Northeast Asia, but leaves China proper alone; China experiences an even more divisive warlord era and ultimately gets reunified by the Communists; South America becomes a full player into these global trends and gets reshaped in the process.
ITTL the Great War occurred earlier, and engulfed pretty much all the OTL warring powers except the USA, plus a few OTL neutrals. The war resulted in an exhausting stalemate, which ensued in revolutionary collapse of the belligerent states. The revolutionary wave caused by the war swept the developed world and typically took the form of a three-way fight for power between the Communists and radical far-leftists, the reactionary and fascist far-rightists, and a democratic coalition of social democrats, Christian democrats, and progressive liberals.
In Russia and Eastern Europe, the Communists prevailed much like OTL and established the USSR, except the mindset became dominant in the leadership to regard ‘world revolution’ as a compelling, persistent goal. Running on revolutionary enthusiasm and aided by local Red insurgents despite terrible logistic difficulties, the Soviets consolidated their power across Russia and swept Central Europe, the Balkans, and the Near East. Their rampage only got stopped when they tried to invade Germany and Italy. A hastily assembled Western European coalition stopped the Red Army and pushed them back. However the war and the revolutionary wave it caused made the new European leaders fearful a prolonged conflict might rekindle dire instability at home.
So once they secured their control of eastern Germany, a border strip of Congress Poland, Bohemia-Moravia, Austria, northern Italy, the Austrian Littoral, Carniola, and Dalmatia they gave up trying to liberate Eastern Europe and made peace with the Soviets. In the Middle East, the British intervened to stop the Reds and they were able to push them out of the Arab lands. However they too failed to dislodge the Soviets and their allies from Anatolia and Persia, and eventually made peace on the basis of military facts on the ground.
The USSR annexed Finland, the Baltic states, Congress Poland, Slovakia, Hungary, Romania, eastern Anatolia, and northwestern Persia as various SSRs. It set up the Balkan Federation (a union of Yugoslavia, Bulgaria, Albania, and Greece), Turkey, and Iran as Communist satellite states. After their initial expansionist rampage had been checked, the Soviet leaders turned to consolidate and develop their vast empire. However they never lost sight of their long-term goal of a world revolution led by Moscow. So they engaged in ruthless brute-force industrialization and massive military build-up of the Soviet empire.
They also fostered destabilization of the capitalist powers and their colonial empires by supporting Communist, far-leftist, and radical nationalist movements across the world. The Soviet army and secret police brutally crushed any opposition to Communist rule in Russia, Eastern Europe, and the Near East by any means available, including extensive massacres, mass deportations, and use of chemical weapons. Large-scale purges and generous use of the gulag system tried hard to wipe out all real, potential, or imagined disloyalty to the Soviet regime.
The British kept control of the Arab lands, and they organized them in a few Kingdoms that became client states of the British Empire. Such states included: Egypt, which annexed North Sudan; Greater Syria, that encompassed the Mashriq (Syria, Lebanon, Palestine, Jordan, Iraq, Kuwait, and Khuzestan) and was ruled by the Hashemites; and Arabia, which included the entire Arabian Peninsula (Hejaz, Nejd, Hadramaut, and Eastern Arabia) and was ruled by the Rashids. The new British regime turned hostile to the Zionist homeland project in Palestine, causing it to wither away. Right-wing Greek refugees took over Crete and the Ionian and Aegean islands and set up a far-right Greek state. It became a client of the British Empire and the British ceded it Cyprus in exchange for basing rights.
In France, Germany, Italy, and the Low Countries the coalition of the liberal-democratic forces (social democrats, Christian democrats, progressive liberals and republicans) defeated the opposition of monarchist-militarist reactionaries, fascists, and Communists and set up a series of progressive states. With their help, the democratic movements were able to win the civil wars in Spain and Portugal too; the hastily assembled European alliance stopped and repelled Soviet invasion of Western Europe. The Great War and the way it ended considerably discredited ethnic nationalism among the European leaders and masses. This combined with various other factors (ideological affinity, the threats of communism and fascism, concerns about political and economic stability, fear of new fratricidal wars) soon persuaded the Western Europeans that continental unity was the only way for peace and prosperity.
The Western European peoples (French, Germans, Italians, Iberians, Dutch, Czechs, Slovenes, West Poles, and Dalmatian Croats) bound themselves into the European Union, a liberal democratic union of states that fairly quickly evolved into a federation similar to the USA. In its mature form it managed foreign affairs, defense with a Pan-European army, complete economic integration with monetary and fiscal union, free movement of goods and people with a common market, an European citizenship with open internal borders, and cooperation in judicial and police affairs. Member states kept autonomy in many domestic issues although European law was paramount. A semi-presidential government managed the various aspects of federal integration with a directly elected assembly, a senate appointed by national parliaments, a supranational executive accountable to the parliament, and a President elected by the European people.
The EU system strongly encouraged regional devolution and cultural autonomy for minorities in member states as a way to defuse nationalist issues. Austria willingly joined Germany, Spain and Portugal agreed to merge into a decentralized Iberian Union, and Belgium with Luxemburg was partitioned between its neighbors since war and revolution had destabilized the Belgian state. Certain sensitive areas (Alsace-Lorraine, South Tyrol, Posen and the Polish Border Strip, Bohemia-Moravia, Carniola, Dalmatia) became autonomous regions with special rights for minorities and federal oversight. Brussels became the union’s capital as a federal district.
The EU acknowledged and cherished cultural differences and the equal dignity of European peoples, although in practice the most important nationalities (French, Germans, Italians, Iberians) bound in a power-sharing agreement inevitably got much more influence. It strongly encouraged a Pan-European identity, continental civic nationalism, and a sense of European cultural exceptionalism. The union adopted Ido as a common, politically neutral lingua franca. However a simplified version of Latin also got commonly accepted and used as an alternative auxiliary language. An option between Ido and simplified Latin became mandatory in European schools; fluency in either language gradually became a de facto prerequisite to belong in European elites, middle classes, and public sector.
The European system guaranteed and praised civil rights and liberal democracy, although it banned and suppressed fascist and communist parties, radical nationalist movements, and other forms of violent political extremism. The Western European people got universal suffrage in European, national, regional, and local elections; together with the USA, the EU led the world in establishing women’s suffrage and a functional welfare state. Political stability and unification of European markets with free movement of goods and people ushered in economic stabilization that soon blossomed into steady development, an industrial boom, and a considerable degree of prosperity for Western Europe. To further recovery and help provide for political stability and common defense the EU leaders engaged in an ambitious program of infrastructure development, industrial build-up, and land reform with preferential dual use. Many projects were funded for the building of useful works such as government buildings, airports, hospitals, schools, roads, bridges, railroads, canals, and dams.
The process spread industrialization across the continent and ensured the least developed nations and regions of the EU (e.g. eastern Germany, Iberia, southern Italy, rural France) all but closed the socio-economic and infrastructure gap with the most advanced areas. The EU (and the USA) led the world in establishing a extensive set of reforms to deal with the social ills created by laissez-faire capitalism and early industrialization, including a graduated income tax and inheritance tax, job safety laws, reduction of working hours, regulation of child labor, establishment of a minimum wage, an end to government interference in peaceful labor disputes to back the employers, a fairly comprehensive welfare system with social security and health care, environmental conservation, a farmer subsidies system, and protection of labor organizing. Political stability, economic prosperity, progressive reforms, and the authoritarian threats looming at the border did a lot to cement the loyalty of Western European peoples to the EU project. The ones who disagreed mostly chose immigration.
The looming threat of a conflict with the Soviet bloc or less likely the fascist British Empire and its allies drove the EU to pursue an ambitious rearmament program and keep a Cold War stance towards its authoritarian neighbors, especially the ever-threatening USSR. The Pan-European military was set up as a common army divided into national components at the battalion level with centralized military procurement and a common budget, arms, and institutions. It became the protector of European independence, an hallmark of unification and reconciliation, and a guarantee the fratricidal wars of the past would not repeat.
Strong aspirations to push the Soviet threat away from Western Europe’s borders, liberate the rest of Europe and North Africa from communism and fascism, and assimilate them in the European project lingered in the EU elites and public, although not to the point of starting a conflict on Europe’s own initiative. Some resentment for the loss of colonies initially existed as well, but it increasingly got discredited over time as the Europeans largely came to regard colonialism as wasteful and morally suspect. This viewpoint got especially strengthened after colonialism turned more and more brutal under fascist management. The EU kept very friendly relations and flourishing trade with the democratic powers of the USA, the Japanese Empire, and the Southern American Union, typically only marred by the occasional trade dispute.
Political changes and conflicts in Europe, Soviet aggressive expansion in the Baltic region, and the home-rule issues of Norway and Iceland drove the Nordic states to bind together for mutual help and protection. Denmark, Norway, Sweden, and Iceland bonded into the Nordic Union, a confederation that managed issues such as foreign affairs, defense, currency, and trade, and left member states autonomous in domestic matters. Concerns about sovereignty, cultural differences, and neutrality initially made the Nordic nations opt out of the European unification process and instead pursue a regional integration project of their own. However the EU and the NU soon established close economic and political bonds and an informal but solid military cooperation, even if the Nordics remained officially neutral.
Over time political, economic, and military ties and cooperation between the two unions and affinities between their systems grew ever greater. At the same time, the Soviet and British threat, with a pattern of recurrent border and naval incidents with both powers and the growth of Soviet military power and aggressiveness in the Baltic, made the Nordics increasingly question the value of their neutrality. Eventually the NU decided to throw sovereignty and neutrality scruples away and petition to join the EU. It was admitted as a sub-federation that enabled member states to keep autonomy in domestic matters and deal as a whole with the European government. All but the smallest EU member states had embraced sub-federalism or regional devolution on their own, so the Nordic requests were granted without any real difficulty.
ITTL the Great War occurred earlier, and engulfed pretty much all the OTL warring powers except the USA, plus a few OTL neutrals. The war resulted in an exhausting stalemate, which ensued in revolutionary collapse of the belligerent states. The revolutionary wave caused by the war swept the developed world and typically took the form of a three-way fight for power between the Communists and radical far-leftists, the reactionary and fascist far-rightists, and a democratic coalition of social democrats, Christian democrats, and progressive liberals.
In Russia and Eastern Europe, the Communists prevailed much like OTL and established the USSR, except the mindset became dominant in the leadership to regard ‘world revolution’ as a compelling, persistent goal. Running on revolutionary enthusiasm and aided by local Red insurgents despite terrible logistic difficulties, the Soviets consolidated their power across Russia and swept Central Europe, the Balkans, and the Near East. Their rampage only got stopped when they tried to invade Germany and Italy. A hastily assembled Western European coalition stopped the Red Army and pushed them back. However the war and the revolutionary wave it caused made the new European leaders fearful a prolonged conflict might rekindle dire instability at home.
So once they secured their control of eastern Germany, a border strip of Congress Poland, Bohemia-Moravia, Austria, northern Italy, the Austrian Littoral, Carniola, and Dalmatia they gave up trying to liberate Eastern Europe and made peace with the Soviets. In the Middle East, the British intervened to stop the Reds and they were able to push them out of the Arab lands. However they too failed to dislodge the Soviets and their allies from Anatolia and Persia, and eventually made peace on the basis of military facts on the ground.
The USSR annexed Finland, the Baltic states, Congress Poland, Slovakia, Hungary, Romania, eastern Anatolia, and northwestern Persia as various SSRs. It set up the Balkan Federation (a union of Yugoslavia, Bulgaria, Albania, and Greece), Turkey, and Iran as Communist satellite states. After their initial expansionist rampage had been checked, the Soviet leaders turned to consolidate and develop their vast empire. However they never lost sight of their long-term goal of a world revolution led by Moscow. So they engaged in ruthless brute-force industrialization and massive military build-up of the Soviet empire.
They also fostered destabilization of the capitalist powers and their colonial empires by supporting Communist, far-leftist, and radical nationalist movements across the world. The Soviet army and secret police brutally crushed any opposition to Communist rule in Russia, Eastern Europe, and the Near East by any means available, including extensive massacres, mass deportations, and use of chemical weapons. Large-scale purges and generous use of the gulag system tried hard to wipe out all real, potential, or imagined disloyalty to the Soviet regime.
The British kept control of the Arab lands, and they organized them in a few Kingdoms that became client states of the British Empire. Such states included: Egypt, which annexed North Sudan; Greater Syria, that encompassed the Mashriq (Syria, Lebanon, Palestine, Jordan, Iraq, Kuwait, and Khuzestan) and was ruled by the Hashemites; and Arabia, which included the entire Arabian Peninsula (Hejaz, Nejd, Hadramaut, and Eastern Arabia) and was ruled by the Rashids. The new British regime turned hostile to the Zionist homeland project in Palestine, causing it to wither away. Right-wing Greek refugees took over Crete and the Ionian and Aegean islands and set up a far-right Greek state. It became a client of the British Empire and the British ceded it Cyprus in exchange for basing rights.
In France, Germany, Italy, and the Low Countries the coalition of the liberal-democratic forces (social democrats, Christian democrats, progressive liberals and republicans) defeated the opposition of monarchist-militarist reactionaries, fascists, and Communists and set up a series of progressive states. With their help, the democratic movements were able to win the civil wars in Spain and Portugal too; the hastily assembled European alliance stopped and repelled Soviet invasion of Western Europe. The Great War and the way it ended considerably discredited ethnic nationalism among the European leaders and masses. This combined with various other factors (ideological affinity, the threats of communism and fascism, concerns about political and economic stability, fear of new fratricidal wars) soon persuaded the Western Europeans that continental unity was the only way for peace and prosperity.
The Western European peoples (French, Germans, Italians, Iberians, Dutch, Czechs, Slovenes, West Poles, and Dalmatian Croats) bound themselves into the European Union, a liberal democratic union of states that fairly quickly evolved into a federation similar to the USA. In its mature form it managed foreign affairs, defense with a Pan-European army, complete economic integration with monetary and fiscal union, free movement of goods and people with a common market, an European citizenship with open internal borders, and cooperation in judicial and police affairs. Member states kept autonomy in many domestic issues although European law was paramount. A semi-presidential government managed the various aspects of federal integration with a directly elected assembly, a senate appointed by national parliaments, a supranational executive accountable to the parliament, and a President elected by the European people.
The EU system strongly encouraged regional devolution and cultural autonomy for minorities in member states as a way to defuse nationalist issues. Austria willingly joined Germany, Spain and Portugal agreed to merge into a decentralized Iberian Union, and Belgium with Luxemburg was partitioned between its neighbors since war and revolution had destabilized the Belgian state. Certain sensitive areas (Alsace-Lorraine, South Tyrol, Posen and the Polish Border Strip, Bohemia-Moravia, Carniola, Dalmatia) became autonomous regions with special rights for minorities and federal oversight. Brussels became the union’s capital as a federal district.
The EU acknowledged and cherished cultural differences and the equal dignity of European peoples, although in practice the most important nationalities (French, Germans, Italians, Iberians) bound in a power-sharing agreement inevitably got much more influence. It strongly encouraged a Pan-European identity, continental civic nationalism, and a sense of European cultural exceptionalism. The union adopted Ido as a common, politically neutral lingua franca. However a simplified version of Latin also got commonly accepted and used as an alternative auxiliary language. An option between Ido and simplified Latin became mandatory in European schools; fluency in either language gradually became a de facto prerequisite to belong in European elites, middle classes, and public sector.
The European system guaranteed and praised civil rights and liberal democracy, although it banned and suppressed fascist and communist parties, radical nationalist movements, and other forms of violent political extremism. The Western European people got universal suffrage in European, national, regional, and local elections; together with the USA, the EU led the world in establishing women’s suffrage and a functional welfare state. Political stability and unification of European markets with free movement of goods and people ushered in economic stabilization that soon blossomed into steady development, an industrial boom, and a considerable degree of prosperity for Western Europe. To further recovery and help provide for political stability and common defense the EU leaders engaged in an ambitious program of infrastructure development, industrial build-up, and land reform with preferential dual use. Many projects were funded for the building of useful works such as government buildings, airports, hospitals, schools, roads, bridges, railroads, canals, and dams.
The process spread industrialization across the continent and ensured the least developed nations and regions of the EU (e.g. eastern Germany, Iberia, southern Italy, rural France) all but closed the socio-economic and infrastructure gap with the most advanced areas. The EU (and the USA) led the world in establishing a extensive set of reforms to deal with the social ills created by laissez-faire capitalism and early industrialization, including a graduated income tax and inheritance tax, job safety laws, reduction of working hours, regulation of child labor, establishment of a minimum wage, an end to government interference in peaceful labor disputes to back the employers, a fairly comprehensive welfare system with social security and health care, environmental conservation, a farmer subsidies system, and protection of labor organizing. Political stability, economic prosperity, progressive reforms, and the authoritarian threats looming at the border did a lot to cement the loyalty of Western European peoples to the EU project. The ones who disagreed mostly chose immigration.
The looming threat of a conflict with the Soviet bloc or less likely the fascist British Empire and its allies drove the EU to pursue an ambitious rearmament program and keep a Cold War stance towards its authoritarian neighbors, especially the ever-threatening USSR. The Pan-European military was set up as a common army divided into national components at the battalion level with centralized military procurement and a common budget, arms, and institutions. It became the protector of European independence, an hallmark of unification and reconciliation, and a guarantee the fratricidal wars of the past would not repeat.
Strong aspirations to push the Soviet threat away from Western Europe’s borders, liberate the rest of Europe and North Africa from communism and fascism, and assimilate them in the European project lingered in the EU elites and public, although not to the point of starting a conflict on Europe’s own initiative. Some resentment for the loss of colonies initially existed as well, but it increasingly got discredited over time as the Europeans largely came to regard colonialism as wasteful and morally suspect. This viewpoint got especially strengthened after colonialism turned more and more brutal under fascist management. The EU kept very friendly relations and flourishing trade with the democratic powers of the USA, the Japanese Empire, and the Southern American Union, typically only marred by the occasional trade dispute.
Political changes and conflicts in Europe, Soviet aggressive expansion in the Baltic region, and the home-rule issues of Norway and Iceland drove the Nordic states to bind together for mutual help and protection. Denmark, Norway, Sweden, and Iceland bonded into the Nordic Union, a confederation that managed issues such as foreign affairs, defense, currency, and trade, and left member states autonomous in domestic matters. Concerns about sovereignty, cultural differences, and neutrality initially made the Nordic nations opt out of the European unification process and instead pursue a regional integration project of their own. However the EU and the NU soon established close economic and political bonds and an informal but solid military cooperation, even if the Nordics remained officially neutral.
Over time political, economic, and military ties and cooperation between the two unions and affinities between their systems grew ever greater. At the same time, the Soviet and British threat, with a pattern of recurrent border and naval incidents with both powers and the growth of Soviet military power and aggressiveness in the Baltic, made the Nordics increasingly question the value of their neutrality. Eventually the NU decided to throw sovereignty and neutrality scruples away and petition to join the EU. It was admitted as a sub-federation that enabled member states to keep autonomy in domestic matters and deal as a whole with the European government. All but the smallest EU member states had embraced sub-federalism or regional devolution on their own, so the Nordic requests were granted without any real difficulty.